If you’re craving authentic New York–style pizza without making the trip to NYC, Trattoria E Pizzeria Da Enrico in Columbia is a solid choice. The crust has that classic thin, foldable texture with just the right amount of crisp, and the sauce strikes a nice balance between tangy and savory. You can tell they take pride in keeping it true to New York style.
The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, perfect for a laid-back lunch or dinner. Service was friendly and efficient, even during busy hours. While it’s not quite the same as grabbing a slice in Manhattan, it definitely satisfies the craving without the plane ticket.
Would definitely come back when the pizza craving hits again!
Ben Stein
-
May 10, 2025
Above-average pizza and Italian food for Maryland. This would be (in my opinion) an average pizza place in NYC, which I intend to mean as praise. The slices have good cheese and crust. I appreciate the fact they often have Sicilian slices, a rarity in this area. Their pasta and other Italian food are very good. Their seating area has a casual, comfortable ambiance.
Chris Stenger
-
January 21, 2026
Pizza by the slice which is great. The pizza is not bad, but has too much cheese to be true New York style pizza. That might be more a matter of the local customer base wanting a cheesier slice. Crust is a bit off as well. But at the end of the day, it's not a bad slice of pizza.
Castle Restorations
-
January 09, 2026
I have been going to this restaurant since i was a kid. From about 2001- Today this has been my go to spot to hit whenever i am back in town visiting my family. The owner is a awesome guy he's very nice, he knows me by name, and he always has a smile on his face. They all work incredibly hard at this place and it feels like family when I walk in. The pizza should be reviewed by Dave Portnoy and get a 9.5 rating ( which is the highest score he's ever given to a pizza spot ) Maybe its just because i grew up eating this pizza and now i just love it because it feels like home but I think if you are in the area and you like classic Italian pizza you have to stop by and check it out for yourself! Cheers!
Robert Palfy
-
December 18, 2018
Friendly family atmosphere. Recently remodeled. Great family price point for pizza or a dinner. Carry out. They also serve beer and wine. Been a fan for over 25 years. Can now order via Slice and Carry Out Menu for delivery.
Our Address
8630 Guilford Rd B30, Columbia, MD 21046, USA
Claim Listing: Trattoria E Pizzeria Da Enrico
Please Login or Register an Account to Claim Listing
If you’re craving authentic New York–style pizza without making the trip to NYC, Trattoria E Pizzeria Da Enrico in Columbia is a solid choice. The crust has that classic thin, foldable texture with just the right amount of crisp, and the sauce strikes a nice balance between tangy and savory. You can tell they take pride in keeping it true to New York style. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, perfect for a laid-back lunch or dinner. Service was friendly and efficient, even during busy hours. While it’s not quite the same as grabbing a slice in Manhattan, it definitely satisfies the craving without the plane ticket. Would definitely come back when the pizza craving hits again!
Above-average pizza and Italian food for Maryland. This would be (in my opinion) an average pizza place in NYC, which I intend to mean as praise. The slices have good cheese and crust. I appreciate the fact they often have Sicilian slices, a rarity in this area. Their pasta and other Italian food are very good. Their seating area has a casual, comfortable ambiance.
Pizza by the slice which is great. The pizza is not bad, but has too much cheese to be true New York style pizza. That might be more a matter of the local customer base wanting a cheesier slice. Crust is a bit off as well. But at the end of the day, it's not a bad slice of pizza.
I have been going to this restaurant since i was a kid. From about 2001- Today this has been my go to spot to hit whenever i am back in town visiting my family. The owner is a awesome guy he's very nice, he knows me by name, and he always has a smile on his face. They all work incredibly hard at this place and it feels like family when I walk in. The pizza should be reviewed by Dave Portnoy and get a 9.5 rating ( which is the highest score he's ever given to a pizza spot ) Maybe its just because i grew up eating this pizza and now i just love it because it feels like home but I think if you are in the area and you like classic Italian pizza you have to stop by and check it out for yourself! Cheers!
Friendly family atmosphere. Recently remodeled. Great family price point for pizza or a dinner. Carry out. They also serve beer and wine. Been a fan for over 25 years. Can now order via Slice and Carry Out Menu for delivery.